Murder at the Rummage Sale a new novel by Elizabeth Cunningham
September 1960. Kennedy and Nixon race for the presidency, and the Women of the Church of the Regeneration, aka the WOR, scramble to prepare for the annual rummage sale, an epic event whose modern equivalent is Black Friday at a supermall. Crowds will spill down the church driveway into the street for blocks, especially this year…when everyone will want to view the place where Charlotte Crowely, president of the WOR, was murdered.
On the day the WOR begin sorting donations sublime and ridiculous (a sweater without a neck hole, anyone?) Charlotte is discovered dead in the basement, smothered by a bag of coats still in wrapped in plastic from the drycleaners. The local chief of police quickly rules her death an accident, an unfortunate fall down a steep flight of stairs, a bump on the head, and the coats landing just the wrong way. “Just one of those things, a damn stupid shame, pardon my French, Rev.“
Lucy Way, an older, not-quite-maiden lady with a mystical bent, has her doubts. The coats belonged to her late mother. She brought them to the parish house a week earlier. The church sexton, Frank Lomangino, an ex-con hired by the outspoken, liberal rector Gerald Bradley, carried the coats upstairs for her. Though Charlotte had a reputation for being light-fingered, pocketing little treasures, clothes were not her besetting sin. She had no reason to remove the coats to the basement. By the time Lucy confides her suspicion that Charlotte might have been murdered, Frank, who found the body, has already contaminated the crime scene by simply doing his job.
Though Gerald Bradley is loath to act on Lucy Way’s concern, he has to admit that Charlotte makes a perfect murder victim, the prying, officious woman everyone loved to hate. Who didn’t want to murder her? Including his organist, the irascible German war refugee, Elsa Ebersbach; pesky, pious parishioner Mildred Thomson, who picks her soul as if it were a nose; and even his own wife, Anne, a quiet woman, locked in grief over the death of their son, whose rage smolders behind a dutiful exterior. (Gerald considers the company of too many women an occupational hazard. He is grateful to have Rick Foster, a fellow liberal who is running for Congress, to turn to for camaraderie and advice. He even envies his former sexton, Amos McCready, a misogynous Scot who lives at a home for old soldiers.)
Anne Bradley, a secret unbeliever, finds the unpaid occupation of minister’s wife onerous if not hazardous. She is horrified to find herself appointed head of the rummage sale in Charlotte’s place, another duty to juggle with all her others, including raising her remaining three children largely on her own. (“When do you expect your husband back?” being a ubiquitous and often unanswerable question.) When she realizes that Gerald believes her capable of murder, Anne is shaken from absorption in her grief and joins forces with Lucy in an unofficial, and perilous, amateur investigation.
Unbeknownst to all the adults, the most determined sleuths are Katherine Bradley, the seven-year-old minister’s daughter, and her sworn blood-brother, Frankie Lomangino, Jr. They have seen something no one else knows about— a man in a black sweatshirt (possibly concealing horns and wings) running through the wood next door to the church, the wood with the NO TRESPASSING sign nailed to a tree. From reciting the Lord’s Prayer, Katherine knows trespassing is bad. She braves the wood, anyway, because she is already guilty of a much worse sin, one she confesses to Frankie when they run away to the wood on the morning of the murder.
A vivid portrait of a vanished world, Murder at the Rummage Sale also brings to fresh life the timeless quirks and contradictions of human nature, both the comic and poignant, the murderous and merciful.